Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Pepperoncini's. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
B.L.T. Pizza
Always. Always. Always. Yummy. Don't beat it til you try it. Pizza and salad all in one. Add red pepper
Dirty Steve's Buffalo Wings
Great wings and great pizza. Also a great family place where the kids can run around. We go often.
Dirty Steve's Buffalo Wings
Great wings! Big, Juicy, and Crispy! Dirty Steve's buffalo sauce was great. Nice n spicy🌶! Cheese pizza was fantastic!. NY fold style which we love and can't always find around town. Beer was cold off the draft. Awesome service. Bartender Jim was great my wife ordered a mixed drink an Jim recommended a special which we ended up with two awesome take away cups! Sometimes walking into a new place you feel unwelcome, not here! welcome from the moment we arrived!! Can't wait to return for more great service and food!
Garlic Parmesan Wings
You will NOT be disappointed if you try these wings, I promise you! They are absolutely delicious and addicting! Great for get togethers, your friends will thank you! 🤤
Buffalo Dip
Amazing, we love the food and the bartenders!!!!
Keggers
This was my first time eating at pepperoncini's and the food was amazing. The keggers exceeded my expectations as well as the potato pizza! Service is great, drinks and food are great! Definitely worth a try if you have never been. I will be back for sure!
Soup of the Day
Really enjoy the soups of the day. Had other food as well. The pizza and wings are always a bit with us.
Dirty Steve's Buffalo Wings
The wings were so delicious! Very juicy on the inside, just the right amount of crisp on the outside. The sauce had just enough heat for the buffalo flavor, but not overwhelming. Ready to go back!
BBQ Chicken Pizza
I love the BBQ Chicken Pizza, the Chicken Parm sub is amazing too. Never a disappointment when eating here!
Our Famous Marinated Steak Tip Dinner
Some of the best steak tips you will ever have! Always a go to when I visit.
Sirloin Steak
Pepperoncinis did an amazing job catering an event I hosted. They were able to take the order on somewhat short notice and work with me on a fluctuating guest list to ensure the correct amount of food. Guests raves about the steak, chicken and especially the scallops wrapped in bacon. I would highly recommend this restaurant for their catering services for any event, large or small.
Margherita Pizza
Seems like every sat we order a large extra cheese pizza. Never fails me. Great crust..great sauce. Delicious!!love the margherita pizza. So light and tasty!!!
French Fries
Awesome. Crack sticks!! Better than McDonald's!!!
The Zeus*
The Zeus is the best thing on the menu! The steak is perfectly cooked every time and it fills me up. Also, Jim and Josh are the best bartenders around. Jim makes the best espresso martini in the world with chocolate syrup drizzle!
Chicken Parm Sub
Always great and nice and hot!!!!
Chicken Parm Sub
Great meal-lots of chicken prepared just right. Will order again!
Chicken Fingers
My 3 year old granddaughter loves & says your chicken fingers are best & yummy ! Me to !
Blackened Chicken Carbonara
Amazazing!! My favorite dish outside of the lobster roll!
Chicken Fingers
We went twice in one week because of the GREAT prices, service, and FOOD. It was a friendly atmosphere. Relaxing environment. Heading there now!
Breadsticks
I love their bread YUM YUM MORE BREAD PLEASE give me that BREAD and no I don't mean money LOL
Big Daddy Burger
Came in today for lunch after hearing about how good their burgers were from my coworkers. I was definitely not disappointed. The burger was cooked to perfection and the slice of pepperoni inside was a very unique touch. Although it was about the size of my head, I managed to clean the plate ;). Definitely recommend the Big Daddy Burger!
Steak Tips & Eggs
My favorite dish, the steak tips are the best in town! Like most of the menu! Best place to eat
Dirty Steve's Buffalo Wings
Best wings around! Perfectly good and yummy Steve sauce. Wings have so much meat on them. You won't go hungry after eating these!
BBQ Wings
These wings were great! I used them for a party I had and everyone loved them. Highly recommend!!!
Margherita Pizza
We love the Margherita pizza! The slices of tomato, fresh mozzarella, and basil, amazing! We continue to come back for more!
Meatloaf Melt
After watching the phantom gourmet, we were excited to visit. Definitely not disappointed! Wow. Our party of 4 ordered different meals and all were fantastic. The meatloaf melt served on thicker Texas style toast with mushroom dipping gravy. Yum. Cozy atmosphere. Very welcoming. Our server was knowledgeable and accommodating. We'll definitely be back!! A real diamond in the rough.
Chicken Parm Sub
Saw on phantom gourmet and had to try. And it was well worth it. Had the chicken parm., steak and cheese spring rolls the buffalo chicken tots and a pizza. My son already talking about going back for his birthday dinner. Well worth the trip, we will be back!,,
NEW! Cauliflower Crust Pizza- 12" Cheese
Delicious! You would never know the crust is made out of cauliflower. Only thing. I really wish. Is that the nutritional information was available. Will definitely order again!
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Absolutely phenomenal pizza. We truly enjoyed every last bite. Also tried the steak spring rolls, they were to die for and the dipping sauce was delicious.
Mango Habanero Wings
Wings are bigger than most. Sauce is great.
Sweet Chili Sauce Wings
I have had these wings several times. I absolutely love them. Never disappoint
Godfather Pizza
Satisfies your cravings for just about any meat or veggie!! Super filling!
Turkey Tips w/ Bourbon Glaze
I am a local of 24 years and never tried this place until this past week. Let me tell you, it's all that has been on my mind since I left. Dive bar that will rock you. Web address does not lie. Beer is ice cold and the pizza is the best pizza I have had in a long time. Never family pie night will be Pepperoncini's take out. I had the turkey tips as my main, as well as a delicious cup of tomato soup (I try everyone's tomato soup). Add an EGG to your turkey tips. I sure did and got no strange looks about it either as there is a steak 'n eggs main dish on the menu. To my surprise, they brought the sucker tips out with not 1, but three 3 eggs over medium. WOW! I love this place...headed back to sit at the bar tonight with my gal.
Our Famous Marinated Steak Tip Dinner
Delicious! I hope to go again soon. Great marinade and such tender tips.
Cobb Salad
Love all the food here! Everything I have tried has been great. Bartenders always attentive! I've been enjoying the 3 olive drink specials and have 15 or so colored solo cups to bring with me to OBX and will surely think of Pepps every day on vacation. The acoustic entertainment is fantastic too. Highly recommend !!
Chicken Broccoli Ziti with Alfredo Sauce
My wife had this dish and said it was great. A lot of food with chicken/broccoli cooked just right.
Ghost Pepper Wings
Amazing!! The best wings around!!
Sirloin & Cheese Spring Rolls
These were exactly as I expected! Perfectly crispy spring roll filled with sirloin steak and cheese with a great dipping sauce. I highly recommend these!
NEW! Cauliflower Crust Pizza- 12" Cheese
Tastes just like regular pizza and yet is a better option health-wise. I love all of the various options available here!
Gluten Free Pizza - 11" Cheese
Definitely one of the better GF pizzas I have had and my favorite in the Milford area!
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
January 2020
Coming Soon
December:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL
November:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA
October:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co., Portland, OR
September:
Amanda, Home Restaurant, Los Angeles, CA
August:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill - Columbus, GA
July:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet - Buffalo, NY
June:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar - Cape Cod, MA
May:
Karen, This Little Pig - Amherst, NY
April:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria - Atlanta, GA